Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Lorry driver whose view was blocked by dashboard tray table jailed for killing cyclist

Robert Bradbury's employer knew the tray table was removed so his vehicle could pass its MOT and reinstalled afterwards...

The lorry driver who hit Birmingham cyclist Dr Suzanna Bull because his view was blocked by a dashboard tray table has been jailed for 21 months for causing her death by careless driving. The firm for which he worked has been fined for failing to supervise the use of the tables.

Bull was in a designated cycle lane when she was hit on Pershore Road, Edgbaston, on October 9, 2017.

Robert Bradbury, aged 50, passed her on Pershore Road before pulling up behind a van at a set of lights at the Priory Road junction.

Bull went ahead when the lights turned green and Bradbury turned left into her. The court heard that she was "dragged under the lorry".

The court heard that Bull had been in a position where Bradbury should have seen her, but he failed to do so because a tray-table, a cap, a sat-nav system, a fan, ornaments and other items had been placed in the centre of the dashboard of his 32-tonne Scania.

Asked why he had the tray table, Bradbury said: "Just so I could be one of the lads. They all had one so I got one."

The table’s presence would have meant an MOT failure. Bradbury said he wasn’t aware of this, but the Birmingham Mail reports it was removed before his vehicle’s MOT and reinstalled afterwards.

His employer, S&J Transport, was aware this happened.

PC Mark Crozier, from West Midlands Police’s Serious Collision Investigation Unit, said: “The dashboard tables used by Bradbury and a number of other drivers across the UK are designed to only be used when the vehicle is stationary.

"They are not to be used when driving, as they clearly present a danger. The junk he accumulated on his dashboard contributed to the fatal collision.

“Both Bradbury and his employer knew his view would be impaired, but both their complacency and total lack of regard for the law were the overriding factors that led to the tragic death of Dr Suzanna Bull.

“I hope this sends a serious message to all road hauliers and drivers to review their vehicle checking processes as the safety of all road users is and always should be a priority."

S&J Transport pleaded guilty to failing to discharge its duty contrary to the Health and Safety at Work Act by failing to supervise the use of the tables and was fined £112,500 and ordered to pay £3,000 in costs.

Bradbury was jailed for 21 months and banned from the roads for 34 months.

Asked if he knew who was at fault for the accident during the trial, Bradbury said: "It was six of one and half-a-dozen of the other."

Judge Paul Farrer QC said he saw no signs during the trial that Bradbury believed he was to blame for the death.

Alex has written for more cricket publications than the rest of the road.cc team combined. Despite the apparent evidence of this picture, he doesn't especially like cake.

Add new comment

16 comments

Avatar
brooksby | 5 years ago
0 likes

I was going to say something scathing about the level of remorse and empathy shown by this bloke, but words fail me... no

 

Avatar
Rick_Rude | 5 years ago
3 likes

Looks like he was driving his front room. No wonder he couldn't see anything. 

Avatar
No Reply | 5 years ago
2 likes

21 months? For taking a life? Jesus. Word fail me. 

Avatar
Hamster | 5 years ago
2 likes

With a book value of just under £2million that 5% fine is going to hurt. That comes out of reserves or turnover not covered by business insurance.

Then there's the knock-on when their o licence gets renewed (if it does) and their fleet insurance renews too.

The HSE fines are the ones that get you or anythin with environment is going to sting too.

Avatar
kil0ran | 5 years ago
6 likes

Fucking atrocious sentence. Total lack of remorse and yet he'll still be allowed to drive professionally in a few years. Beggars belief - it wouldn't be the case in maritime/aviation sectors. It's not like we're desperately short of lorry drivers, just ban the fucker for life.

Avatar
mike the bike replied to kil0ran | 5 years ago
4 likes

kil0ran wrote:

Fucking atrocious sentence. Total lack of remorse and yet he'll still be allowed to drive professionally in a few years. Beggars belief - it wouldn't be the case in maritime/aviation sectors. It's not like we're desperately short of lorry drivers, just ban the fucker for life.

 

Life for Bradbury may be harder than you think.  It will be extremely difficult for any employer to find insurance for him and if they do, the cost will be astronomical.  In addition to that hurdle his local traffic commissioners are likely to reject any application for the return of his HGV licence.  His days as a professional driver are probably over.

Avatar
the little onion replied to mike the bike | 5 years ago
4 likes

mike the bike wrote:

kil0ran wrote:

Fucking atrocious sentence. Total lack of remorse and yet he'll still be allowed to drive professionally in a few years. Beggars belief - it wouldn't be the case in maritime/aviation sectors. It's not like we're desperately short of lorry drivers, just ban the fucker for life.

 

Life for Bradbury may be harder than you think.  It will be extremely difficult for any employer to find insurance for him and if they do, the cost will be astronomical.  In addition to that hurdle his local traffic commissioners are likely to reject any application for the return of his HGV licence.  His days as a professional driver are probably over.

 

”probably” isn’t enough. It should definitely be over. As should the careers of his bosses. Wouldn’t be allowed in any other sector. 

Avatar
Awavey replied to mike the bike | 5 years ago
5 likes
mike the bike wrote:

kil0ran wrote:

Fucking atrocious sentence. Total lack of remorse and yet he'll still be allowed to drive professionally in a few years. Beggars belief - it wouldn't be the case in maritime/aviation sectors. It's not like we're desperately short of lorry drivers, just ban the fucker for life.

 

Life for Bradbury may be harder than you think.  It will be extremely difficult for any employer to find insurance for him and if they do, the cost will be astronomical.  In addition to that hurdle his local traffic commissioners are likely to reject any application for the return of his HGV licence.  His days as a professional driver are probably over.

Because we all know the checks any future employer in the truck driving industry are foolproof,never skipped,not who you know etc etc

Avatar
the little onion | 5 years ago
9 likes

why no corporate manslaughter charge? 

Avatar
hmas1974 replied to the little onion | 5 years ago
9 likes
the little onion wrote:

why no corporate manslaughter charge? 

I'd be willing to contribute towards a crowd funded corporate manslaughter case against the haulage firm. Their directors should be joining Bradbury for a spell in prison.

Avatar
Jimmy on wheels replied to hmas1974 | 5 years ago
3 likes

hmas1974 wrote:
the little onion wrote:

why no corporate manslaughter charge? 

I'd be willing to contribute towards a crowd funded corporate manslaughter case against the haulage firm. Their directors should be joining Bradbury for a spell in prison.

Or else his supervisor... basically which ever person or persons approved it/knew about it and didn't tell him to remove it.

Avatar
Pilot Pete | 5 years ago
3 likes

Holy sh1t! 

PP

Avatar
brooksby | 5 years ago
5 likes

Another person considering their vehicle to be an extension of their house...

Avatar
AlsoSomniloquism replied to brooksby | 5 years ago
6 likes

brooksby wrote:

Another person considering their vehicle to be an extension of their house...

 

TBF to long distance lorry drivers, they pretty much are their homes. However what he did was taking the piss somewhat and the fact he removed it for MOT's and his company knew about it and let him do it luckily wasn't ignored by the courts. (although the sentencing as always leaves something to be desired.)

Avatar
ktache | 5 years ago
13 likes

The dashboard table.

Another totally unremorseful highly trained, professional killer driver.

 

Avatar
Jimmy on wheels replied to ktache | 5 years ago
2 likes

ktache wrote:

The dashboard table.

Another totally unremorseful highly trained, professional killer driver.

 

What a f***ing joke. I understand that lorry drivers practically live in their vehicles, but they should be banned from putting any ornamentation in the front section of the cab, no laptops, tablets or screens to distract them or anything that blocks the windscreen (other than perhaps a small GPS somehwere where it can't obscure the view of a cyclist or pedestrian).

Latest Comments