Brighton & Hove City Council is using CCTV cameras to catch and fine drivers who illegally park in cycle lanes – a hazard that forces cyclists riding along them to move out into the main carriageway.
Under legislation introduced in June 2020, councils can use CCTV evidence enabling them to issue penalty charge notices (PCNs) by post.
The Argus reports that up until 17 December, 29 motorists had received fines since the cameras were installed last October in four cycle lanes in the city.
The cycle lanes in question are located on Lewes Road, Preston Road, Preston Drove and West Street.
A fifth location, on London Road, was added on 1 January, and cameras on a sixth, on a separate section of Preston Road, will come into operation from 1 February.
The newspaper says that a Freedom of Information Request showed that as of 17 December, 14 motorists had paid PCNs of £35 each, with 13 fines yet to be paid and two being appealed.
At the time, the city council said: “It is important that the city’s cycle lanes are free for people cycling to use, but sometimes cyclists can find them obstructed by people who have parked inconsiderately.
“People who park in The Lanes are given a short grace period to allow for pick-ups and drop-offs only.”
While it is against the law to park in a cycle lane, enforcement using CCTV can only be done where the location is also subject to restrictions such as a single or double yellow lines, or where kerb markings indicate that loading is not allowed.
A spokesman for Brighton & Hove City Council spokesman commented: “We want to keep Brighton and Hove moving. It’s important that the city’s cycle lanes are free for people cycling to use. But sometimes they can be obstructed by people parking inconsiderately.
“New legislation came into force in June 2020 which meant we can now use cameras as evidence to issue Penalty Charge Notices (PCNs) to people who park in cycle lanes where there are currently restrictions on parking or loading.
“People who park in the lanes are given a short grace period to allow for pick-ups and drop offs only.
“Any surplus generated by parking fees and charges must be spent on provision of public transport services or to road, air quality or environmental improvements
“We use our surplus to provide concessionary bus passes for older and disabled people, subsidising bus routes, road safety and transport improvement projects,” he added.
Councils and road safety partnerships are often accused of using fines imposed on motorists for parking illegally or ignoring speed limits as a ‘cash cow’ to extract money from drivers, although as the council’s response highlights, the money goes towards improvements that benefit all.
Moreover, as is regularly pointed out on social media to those lamenting fines for illegal parking or speeding, there are simple ways to avoid them – namely, only park where it is permitted, and keep within the relevant speed limit.
In December 2020, Thomas Cornwallis, convener of the Strathclyde cycling campaign group GoBike left homemade ‘parking tickets’ (pictured above) on cars illegally parked in a cycle lane outside a school in the Hillhead district of Glasgow – and for his efforts was told to “f*ck off” by an angry motorist he had ‘ticketed’.
> Cyclist leaves homemade parking tickets on cars parked in bike lane opposite school
Add new comment
13 comments
Pedantry note here :
“People who park in The Lanes are given a short grace period to allow for pick-ups and drop-offs only.”
“People who park in the lanes are given a short grace period to allow for pick-ups and drop-offs only.”
There are 2 instances of this sentence but for Brighton specifically they mean different things. The Lanes when capitalised refers to an area of town between the main "high street" and the sea front.
Now my memories of Brighton are fuzzy from time and alcohol but I dont believe any of the named roads with CCTV are within The Lanes so the reference is puzzling.
Also speaking as someone who's just been CCTV ticketed due to filtering into an expiring bus lane 10 meters too early - why should people pulling into the Cycle lane be given any leeway? Surely they should be minimising the amount of traffic crossing into the lane?
I've got a query... can we do a Mikey, and take pictures / footage of the offending parkers. If so, what kind of evidence would we need, who would we need to submit it to, and would the recipient's response depend on their particular stance as regards cycle lanes, single / double lines etc?
I've got a sneaking suspicion I might be able to clear the national debt by Teusday week.
[edit] I have now learned to use the internet, and ascertained the evidence has got to be gathered using an approved device which has to be certified by the Secretary of State.
https://www.local.gov.uk/sites/default/files/documents/200601%20Advice%2...
Bah! Foiled again! Makes noise like Muttley in Wacky Races.
So if I've understood that, the cycle lane is of no significance whatsoever and no consequence arises from parking in the cycle lane - enforcement is taken solely on the basis of other parking restrictions being in place.
The penalty notice will make no mention of the cycle lane, so the message will be that the offence was nothing to do with blocking a cycle lane and endangering cyclists - just a yellow line infraction. Rock on.
So if I've understood that, a quick stop for pick-ups and drop-offs is to be tolerated, presumably because motorists feel that's only reasonable? So let the grace period apply in the motorists' lane, and we'll see how long it is tolerated for then.
Is that because police would have to deal with parking on cycle lanes, but councils can deal with yellow lines?
You're doubtless correct - but it makes a nonsense of the headline and general thrust of the article, basically just shoddy reporting. The best that can be made of it is that the council is prioritising existing parking enforcement where it happens to ovelap with cycle lanes.
I can't be bothered to google and check but seem to recall it is about who can enforce what - councils can enforce parking restrictions against yellow lines and no loading markings but I think it has to be the police to enforce the cycle lane parking, also think that it has been confused by recent traffic sign legislation which basically provides a loophole that only lanes painted before a certain date are illegal to park in and ones painted after that date are not (unless yellow lines etc.)
Given many "cycle lanes" are actually bus lanes in part / whole, and those can wink into and out of existence depending on time of day, and indeed in Edinburgh there are bus lanes with marked parking inside them I think we can conclude that we need some updated stationary: "YPLAC - and the worst you'll get for that is this sticker".
I like the card on the photo. Is that something someone's put together themselves or can you buy them?
It says that the one in the photo was made by a member of the Strathclyde cycling campaign, GoBike. On their website, they have a different downloadable design under resources: https://www.gobike.org/about-us/gobike-resources
Didn't read that bit, sorry <wrist slap> - got distracted by work...
Was it a Cabernet Sauvignon?
They just used information that I requested, which i found a little funny when I saw it appear on the argus.
The orignal request, which shows a bit more info is here:
https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/parking_enforcement_cameras
Well done Internet person!