Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

news

Driver avoids prison sentence after mowing down cyclist for 'riding over a bridge'

The motorist was given a 12 month community order and banned from driving for 12 months

A driver has avoided being jailed after he deliberately crashed into a cyclist because the man 'cycled over a bridge'.

Muir David Taylor, 65,  'started going mental' and swerved into the rider, knocking the man into a busy road.

He then drove off, leaving the victim lying injured on the floor. 

Taylor appeared at Plymouth Crown Court, Devon, for sentence having pleaded guilty to dangerous driving.

Prosecuting the case, Emily Cook described how on November 6 last year the victim  was cycling behind Taylor on the Tamar Bridge when Taylor took exception to him, Cornwall Live reports.

Taylor slowed down so the cyclist had to stop and the pair exchanged words.

After leaving the bridge Taylor should have turned right but instead, without indicating, swerved left across two lanes of traffic to get in front of the rider.

The cyclist pulled up and Taylor told him not to cycle on the bridge with witnesses describing him as 'going mental'.

Taylor then deliberately drove into the cyclist, knocking him over and into a live lane of traffic.

He then accelerated away but witnesses were able to identify his vehicle to police and Taylor was traced and arrested.

The victim was lucky to only suffer minor injuries but has been left shaken by the ordeal.

Sentencing Taylor, Judge Robert Linford said: “You lost your temper and at some point your vehicle hit a cyclist. This was extremely dangerous driving because you lost your temper.

“That said this is the only time you’ve done anything wrong in your entire life and you have expressed an appropriate level of remorse.

“I note the problems that beset your life prior to this incident.”

Taylor was given a 12 month community order consisting of a mental health treatment requirement and a rehabilitation activity requirement. He was also banned from driving for 12 months.

Add new comment

69 comments

Avatar
Owd Big 'Ead | 3 years ago
16 likes

That he was going through problems in his life prior to the incident should be no reason whatsoever to giving him a slap on the wrists.

All this does is give every psychopath in a car an easy excuse to explain their utterly shite driving.

If the judges cannot give appropriate punishments they might be in the wrong job.

Avatar
Captain Badger replied to Owd Big 'Ead | 3 years ago
5 likes

Owd Big 'Ead wrote:

That he was going through problems in his life prior to the incident should be no reason whatsoever to giving him a slap on the wrists.

All this does is give every psychopath in a car an easy excuse to explain their utterly shite driving.

If the judges cannot give appropriate punishments they might be in the wrong job.

Quite. There are two things that must be applied here.

  1. REvocation of driving licence till such a time he can demonstrate that he's back on track and fit to be in charge of a vehicle looks after protection of the wider public
  2. Suitable punishment for an unprovoked grievous attack on a vulnerable member of the public.

The former is independent of sympathy and must be totally objective. The latter is where you can play to teh gallery to show what a kind-hearted judge you are.

 

Avatar
leaway2 | 3 years ago
3 likes

Speechless!

Avatar
hawkinspeter | 3 years ago
22 likes

Should be a custodial sentence just for the hit and run aspect. That it was completely intentional should mean a lifetime driving ban - he does not have the emotional composure to not endanger others.

Avatar
CXR94Di2 | 3 years ago
18 likes

Dangerous driving with intent to cause injury, should carry mandatory prison sentence. Minimum 1 yr prison sentence, 5yr driving ban to start after prison release. Then an extended driving test.

Avatar
open_roads replied to CXR94Di2 | 3 years ago
21 likes

Why should someone who has deliberately hit another road user with a vehicle because of their inability to control their temper ever be allowed to drive again?

If someone shoots a stranger with a shotgun they are never allowed to hold a shotgun license again - so why should we as a society accept a lower punishment just because the weapon of choice has four wheels.?

Avatar
Secret_squirrel | 3 years ago
22 likes

OMFG.  I despair of some of our judges.  This moron assaults someone with a deadly weapon and pushes him into a main road with a high rate of traffic and he gets off without any kind of custodial sentence.    If he had knocked a pedestrian into the road with a baseball bat would the judge have been as lenient?

Avatar
wtjs replied to Secret_squirrel | 3 years ago
6 likes

 I despair of some of our judges

Agreed. Judge Linford is highly unlikely to be a cyclist.

Avatar
Losd | 3 years ago
20 likes

Using a heavy vehicle as a weapon should ALWAYS lead to prison sentences. And long ones at that.

Pages

Latest Comments