In a Tour which has had everything so far, from the engrossing general classification battle of Tadej Pogačar and Jonas Vingegaard, Mark Cavendish winning his 35th stage, Romain Bardet in yellow in his last rodeo, Remco Evenepoel winning a time trial on his debut… I can keep going on.
But one of the best, if not the best, storyline to come out of this race has been the success of Biniam Girmay, the Intermarché-Wanty rider from Eritrea who was initially drafted in the team to support sprinter Gerben Thijssen, but has instead made the show all about him, not only becoming the first black African rider to win a Tour de France stage, but going on to win two more and grab the green jersey.
> “It’s our moment, it’s our time”: History-maker Biniam Girmay becomes first black African rider to win a Tour de France stage in chaotic sprint in Turin
Despite his crash in the final two kilometres yesterday, Biniam still has a 32-point lead over last year’s green jersey winner Jasper Philipsen, and with all sprint stages, this battle looks set to go down to the wire.
Meanwhile, back in Asmara, Eritrea’s capital, people have taken to the streets to celebrate their home hero, with cycling going higher and higher in popularity in the country
However, with Biniam still the only black cyclist in the pro peloton, fans have criticised a French documentary about the 24-year-old where the interviewer asks him a strange question, but his response is even more graceful and commendable.
“Maybe it’s a strange question, but how was your childhood?” the interviewer asks in the documentary titled C’est mon tour (‘It’s my turn’). “Did you have trouble with money? Was cycling a way to get out of…”
Biniam replies: “No, this question is bad. My family is not rich, not poor. They are alright, they have everything. Cycling is my passion, I don’t do it to get money or rich.”
Fans have criticised this question from the documentary which aired in April this year, with a Twitter account writing: “Such an insanely reductive framing of an entire continent as large as Africa, it's unreal.”
Other people pointed out the subtle racism, saying that the same question doesn’t get asked to former pro from South Africa Daryl Impey who wore the yellow jersey in 2013, or Biniam’s teammate South African teammate Louis Meintjes, or even four-time Tour winner Chris Froome, who grew up in Kenya.
However, some people also noted the reportedly poor economic conditions of Eritrea, most notably caused by global sanctions imposed by the west due to the country’s Marxist-Lenninist government which rose to power after the Eritrean War of Independence.
What do you think? Was the question justified or is this yet another case of deep-rooted racism?
Add new comment
44 comments
Road.cc seems to a gift for digging up comments from slightly obscure groups. (Of course it could be me but) I've never heard of "Cooperative mobility UK". From their website : "1999 - CoMoUK created as Community Car Share Network (CCSN)"
Not quite sure what they've to do with cycling? They list an interest in "shared bikes and ebikes" but they mainly seem to be about motorised stuff - in particular the e-motorised or "tech-enhanced".
Not saying they're suspect (though perhaps a quick perusal of funding in order) or this isn't a good idea; only that:
a) without places to cycle (or ride your e-scooter, another thing they're keen on) most people won't cycle / ride. I am not keen on creating more conflict / hazards by chucking them onto UK "shared use" facilities (or even footways, with escooters).
b) Sharing (outside existing public transport) sounds a good idea, it's a "we can do right now" ... only people have either already done it or they don't. I suggest what people have shown they want is private, personal transport. They're also OK with public transport if it's extremely reliable and frequent. And strangely the two (eg. cycling and trains) combine very well also. I wonder ... any examples of where that utopia exists...?
Oh - and they needn't campaign about escooters; AFAIKS there's zero interest in regulating / policing their use...
Road cc, how come you or your affiliates don't appear to be on the list of publications regulated by IPSO?
As 'the go-to publisher for UK cyclists, with an audience of 10 million cyclists (and growing)' surely you must be open to the same publishing regulations that other cycling publications are?
Pffft! More than 1 in 7 of the UK population?
This 'monthly community reach' appears to mean 'anyone who was exposed to anything related to road.cc, anywhere, whether they paid any attention to it or not'. It's a bit of a stretch to imply that all of them are 'going to' road.cc.
Membership of IPSO is voluntary and a number of media organisations, including the Financial Times, The Guardian and The Independent choose not to participate, instead running their own complaints system. IPSO's lack of independence has been described as "a sham" by Hacked Off and it is not supported by the NUJ. Road.cc has every right not to participate in IPSO if it so chooses.
Ta for that, it got me looking at some interesting articles. Everyday's a learning day.
I'm surprised at the reaction to the King's Speech: I thought it was an excellent movie.
Well, kind of. It might be Hautes-Alpes, but it's not particularly, er, haute - have to wait until Friday for that.
If you do the same jouney (Commute) on a bicycle and in a car you are 49 times more likely to be killed or seriously injured on the bike.
If there is a high incidecnce of heart attacks in the population as a whole cycling could still be statistically beneficial.
I hate Statistics!
Got a link to the study that shows that please?
100% of people swimming across crocodile-infested rivers survive, as long as they aren't eaten by a crocodile.
Not true: 10% of them drown naturally. Apparently caused by eating ice cream.
It's shark attackes that are caused by eating ice cream
There's a parallel crossing like the one illustrated above near me in Peckham on a route I use regularly, twice since it was installed have cars actually stopped for me out of probably 150 times I've used it. However, just this once I don't completely blame drivers as it's not infrastructure with which most people in this country are familiar (I believe), they see the zebra crossing and roll up to that as their stop marker as they are accustomed to do. Better signage on the approach warning that there is a cycle and pedestrian crossing coming up would help a lot; additionally, instead of adding confusing extra lines, why not just have a double width zebra crossing with appropriate markings to show which side is for cyclists and which for pedestrians?
I think that's right: drivers don't particularly know that these are to be treated as zebra crossings, and the visuals of them next to zebra crossings give the impression that they are something that isn't a zebra crossing. Signage on the approaches would certainly help.
They also seem to suffer from being dropped in to existing pedestrian crossing locations without any consideration for how actual cyclists would approach them. The ones I use most often (off Walworth Road and on the way to Crystal Palace) are located on sharp bends with poor sightlines as you ride towards them. Even knowing that I have priority, it's pretty rare that I don't have to slow to a near-stop just to be able to get a view of the traffic in all directions. Which is fine, I'm crossing a road, but the lines make it feel like I'm also on a road and should proceed at normal road speed. I might as well (and occasionally do) just use the actual zebra crossing which was already there and which drivers in general can be relied on to stop for.
"Cycling your commute can lower risk of death by 47%..."
Does this mean being a cycling commuter that we have a 47% chance of IMMORTALITY...?
Surely that would be headline news around the world if it was true.
So far, only about 93% of humans who have ever lived, have died. So there's a chance.
We might be getting there
[...in mice]
I am planning on living for ever. So far, so good.
Horsist video of dangerous driving
Only got an twitter link
https://x.com/ES_News_/status/1812803478600761647
Comes off a bend at high speed, onto the verge and almost loses control on the verge and after when rejoining the road.
I'm sure that idiot's car insurance company would love to know about it.
All car tax and MOT statuses are publically available on gov.uk website. Imagine a database with their insurance status and policy insurer. The amount of clips circling round half of all policies would be revoked very quickly. But with an estimated 1 million uninsured drivers (and probably more considering the cost of living crisis) out there, I am not sure how effective it would be. Also, some people change insurers regularly because there are always cheaper quotes. I've had 4 different insurers in just over 10 years of driving. The first was an under-25 specialist (black box fitted). After 5 years I sold my little hatchback and had an estate, and my existing provider was no longer the cheapest. Since then I haven't been with the same insurer for longer than 3 years.
Given the piss poor driving I suspect that the person driving the car didn't have the owner's consent.
King's Speech - Full List of Bills
Not sure if Death by Dangerous Cycling will be in the Crime and Policing Bill, there's no explicit mention of it.
Labour were supportive of crating the offence provided it came as part of an overall reform to improve road safety. Whether that means better resources for road policing, tougher penalties or even just higher conviction rates is unclear but until they lay out any detailed plans we cannot know.
There are many other problems facing the Government at the moment, and this may not be as high a priority as others.
I think this is the same documentary- same credits etc..
hopefully will give it a bit more context than a couple of screen grabs on Twitter.
https://www.timescapes.be/films/this-is-my-moment
Synopsis
Biniam Girmay, a 17 year old promising cyclist from the African country Eritrea, dreams of one day riding the Tour de France, the most prestigious Grand Tour in the world.
For years he thought the Tour was only for European or white cyclists, as over its more than 100 editions, only a handful of the participants were black.
Biniam’s evolving performances give a rare insight into cycling in Africa.
But to make it into an international Pro Team, Europe’s visa procedures are a constant hassle. And once he marries in Eritrea and becomes a father, the distance of 6.000kms takes its toll. Against all odds, Biniam climbs up the international rankings. When at age 21, he wins his first ‘Classic’, he proves African riders can win big races. He becomes a cycling hero overnight, but can he change cycling forever?
‘This is my moment’ gives a unique insight into Biniam Girmay’s climb to success and to adulthood. For more than six years, Lieven Corthouts was the only friend and filmmaker allowed to film Biniam's life in Eritrea as well as in Europe. Having Biniam also filming with a vlogging camera, they have made this film together in a co-creation process.
To the bus driver who thinks cyclists should only use cycle lanes...
What about when the "cycle lane" randomly stops/disappears like at the end of the clip?
Where do we go then?
And lets not forget the bus driver who told me I have to stop when I reach a bus stop and look around before proceeding:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SF4u42-lx84
https://road.cc/content/news/near-miss-day-881-304795
I'd love to know how the conversation with her manager went.
So, surely motorists should only use motorways?
Motorways without cyclists & therefore only used by 'highly trained & licenced drivers', so never any speeding or collisions
I like the idea of illustrated cycle lanes - maybe something from this or this to start us off?
This one's colourful:
https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2021/06/16/the-worlds-longest-rainbow...
If we're happy to expand it to tunnels then there's a wider field:
https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2020/02/05/cheerful-art-in-a-cycle-tu...
https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2011/11/24/benelux-cycling-tunnel-rot...
Parallel crossings: I had an extended debate with a driver after he failed to give way to another cyclist. At the start it was quite heated, but amazingly he actually accepted that he was in the wrong and had learned something new. However, I could see his point - the priority is not clear. For example, in the picture in the article above, why is there a given way line for the cyclist if they have priority?
Pages