Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

news

Strava no longer allows you to add links to uploads and deletes all old ones: frustrated users hit out at social fitness giant that claims "ongoing situation" of URL removal "necessary to protect the community"

Strava blames "sustained campaign of inauthentic content posted to the platform" — but users have questioned the knock-on effect, particularly for those raising money for charity who now can't share fundraising links...

Strava will no longer let you add URL links to posts and has deleted all links in existing posts, a move that has been criticised by some users frustrated by the inconvenience and impact it could have, particularly on those hoping to raise money for charity.

Users noticed URLs being automatically removed from posts over the past couple of weeks, new uploads no longer showing the link and existing uploads now displaying a 'This content is not available' message.

Strava URL removal message

And while there will be plenty of users hearing the news relatively unbothered, there have been frustrations aired from others expressing disappointment at the policy which will make life tougher for those who want to share links on their posts — whether that be to an event or race page, results list, sportive sign-up, charity fundraiser, club page on social media, personal social media account, YouTube video, or the numerous other things someone may wish to share with their Strava followers.

It is not clear if it is a permanent policy at this point. We contacted Strava for clarification about if links will be allowed again in the future, and to ask about the potential impact it could have on people raising money for charity, but were told the ride-sharing app has nothing to add beyond what is already in its Community Hub.

There Strava says it is an "ongoing situation" that comes in response to "a sustained campaign of inauthentic content posted to the platform" that requires "certain necessary steps to safeguard the community".

Recently our team has been dealing with a sustained campaign of inauthentic content posted to the platform and as a result we have taken certain necessary steps to safeguard the community. One of the many measures we have taken is filtering links across multiple app surfaces. This was necessary to protect the community from harmful and violating content. We recognise that this has impacted many of you. We are also aware that non-links were inadvertently included in this filtering and we apologise for the disruption this has caused.

Community safety is our highest priority, and we will take any action necessary to protect them. As this is an ongoing situation, we do not currently have a timeline for when the filtering of links will end, but we appreciate the community's patience as we work to keep everyone on Strava safe.

Needless to say, the situation has prompted plenty of discussion online, one user also sharing a picture of a communication they received from Strava's Trust & Safety Team, in which the user is told "we are unable to lift the restriction at this time" and that Strava is "firmly committed to athlete safety [...] We also take our compliance with legal requirements very seriously. To this end, we have implemented mechanisms to detect and prevent suspicious or unsafe activity on Strava."

There was also a suggestion in some forums that even links to pages on Strava (such as groups or challenges) would be removed, although when we tried this earlier today we were still able to link to pages on Strava within activities. A link we included to a JustGiving page was however removed from the post.

One user posted on the Community Hub that: "Between the inaction regarding the clutter in the feed for ages, and now this censorship, I just cancelled my premium features after 11 years."

Another wrote: "What they've done here—both in preventing links from being posted, and worse, in modifying user-contributed personal content—are serious breaches of trust. Their response to this has been insufficient, off the cuff, and frankly rings of adolescence. I get so much value from Strava that I will have a hard time cancelling my Pro subscription but I am very seriously considering it. It's not just these actions, but what it shows more deeply about how they view their customer base.

> Even if it's on Strava, it might not have happened — some cyclists are paying 'mules' to ride activities for them

"I just can't get over how inappropriate, rash, and incompetent it was of them to to edit people's past content, including that of all paying customers. Outrageous."

Someone else replied: "I hope they bring links back. Posting the song of the ride is the reason why I bother to write a post at all! Don't call yourself social media, make me pay for it, and then not allow anyone to share any links."

A quick visit through high-profile athletes' pages shows the new Strava world without links, Chris Froome's much criticised posts advertising mobile banking app Curve now looking like this.

Strava links remove Froome's Curve link

You may not miss that, but users have pointed out the potential implications for clubs, individuals, events and everyday use. Some of the complaints online are about the impact on communities, clubs or groups — as well as individual users, plenty of whom already pay a subscription each month, being inconvenienced.

Whether that be a cycling YouTuber now unable to leave an easily accessible URL to their latest video, a club being unable to link the sign-up page of an upcoming event it is hosting, an athlete being unable to share a results page of the race they finished, or a rider raising money for charity being unable to link their fundraising page, from the reaction online there are plenty who have been left scratching their heads.

But what do you think? Had you even noticed the change? Will it affect your use of the app? Let us know in the comments...

Dan is the road.cc news editor and joined in 2020 having previously written about nearly every other sport under the sun for the Express, and the weird and wonderful world of non-league football for The Non-League Paper. Dan has been at road.cc for four years and mainly writes news and tech articles as well as the occasional feature. He has hopefully kept you entertained on the live blog too.

Never fast enough to take things on the bike too seriously, when he's not working you'll find him exploring the south of England by two wheels at a leisurely weekend pace, or enjoying his favourite Scottish roads when visiting family. Sometimes he'll even load up the bags and ride up the whole way, he's a bit strange like that.

Add new comment

15 comments

Avatar
NotNigel | 2 months ago
0 likes

This is made all the worse by not being able to grab any text in Strava, well not on the app using iPhone, and being able to copy and paste any text. i.e. a web address for a just giving page.

Avatar
Vegan Dave | 2 months ago
0 likes

I dunno, is Strava unique in having 'bad urls' posted? Why does nearly every other site on the planet (universe?) allow urls, and why is Strava uniquely unable to resolve this, resorting to such a neolithic cudgle of a 'solution'?

Ban the accounts of bad actors, and identify the patterns of these accounts, and prevent them from signing up in the first place. Add a 'report bad url' option. Lots of other ways to go about this.

It does scew over a number of users - I also use Strava to organize a competition series (search for the Victoria Segment Challenge, it's based on the KOMpetitions that sprung up during covid, I run this one here in Victora, BC Canada), and so now the links to my site are MIA.

And the link to the weekly update/newsletter I put out.

And the link to the extended helpful info I post for the segments each week on my site.

Honestly at this point it would be more convienient for me to move my series OFF Strava.

And despite being a paid subscriber for many years, they never replied to my support requests.

Nice work, Strava.

Avatar
JJD. | 2 months ago
0 likes

Since January of this year, I’ve stopped using Strava and now ride purely for myself. It’s just me, my bike, and the open road—no metrics, no competition, no need for comparison.

Every ride feels like true freedom, as if I’ve broken free from a self-imposed cage.....

Avatar
Global Nomad | 2 months ago
1 like

Strava may have had good intentions to avoid undesirable content, but it has implimented it in a very blunt manner....and being clumsy and cheap is not a good look. It is surely entirely possible to remove or block only links that are flagged or problematic and keep all the valid ones.
They have taken a similarly clumsy approach to 'decluttering' segments - removing overlapping or duplicates in a clumsy way so various data dispaears from users and apps that use particular data.
All the while still not removing dodgy activities on segment leader boards.

Avatar
Jimmy Ray Will | 2 months ago
2 likes

My initial thought is that a new, premium subscriber package that allowed linking and promotion is about to be launched. So your Froome's and 'influencers' can continue posting links to their content / sponsors, it'll just cost them a little more to do so. 

Gotta love it. 

Avatar
marqueemark | 2 months ago
4 likes

Further Enshitification of Strava. 
 

Avatar
snooks replied to marqueemark | 2 months ago
1 like

Safety is not their highest priority that's for sure.  In order to make more money selling user data they made it easy for stalkers to go after female users.

Avatar
Svetty | 2 months ago
1 like

Tricky. If someone clicks on a link within Strava that sends them to a phishing site or malicious software download they might be a bit pissed off......

Avatar
mark1a replied to Svetty | 2 months ago
0 likes

Svetty wrote:

Tricky. If someone clicks on a link within Strava that sends them to a phishing site or malicious software download they might be a bit pissed off......

I think it was a bit worse than that for Strava. AFAIK, multiple fake accounts were being created, which then created posts & activities containing adverts for dodgy content, this was at such a volume it was gaming the search engine algorithms to return results for adverts hosted at Strava. 

That said, if this is true, removing both the capability of post links, and all historic links  from all user content seems like a very blunt approach in my opinion, so unless this was even worse, such as XSS attack risks, then this could have been handled better. 

Avatar
Pot00000000 | 2 months ago
4 likes

This sector needs a shake up and Strava needs a competitor. 
 

Avatar
Ramz replied to Pot00000000 | 2 months ago
1 like

There are several. We need to settle on one. My vote is for komoot.

Avatar
Pot00000000 replied to Ramz | 2 months ago
0 likes

I should have said, I'm interested in segments and KOMs not navigation aids. 

 

Avatar
rct replied to Pot00000000 | 2 months ago
0 likes

You can get those on Garmin Connect now.

Avatar
snooks replied to Pot00000000 | 2 months ago
0 likes

Strva just didn't want to maintain this thats all.

Avatar
Fursty Ferret | 2 months ago
2 likes

There seems to be a weird connection between brands with bright orange logos and having the customer service skills of a teaspoon.

Latest Comments