Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

forum

Permanent Revocation of Driving Licence

Mr PJ Casey has created an e-Petition calling for drivers who cause death by either dangerous or careless driving to have their licences revoked for life. The link is below.

http://epetitions.direct.gov.uk/petitions/68675

I think this e-Petition is worthy of our support. Please sign and spread the word.

Thank you for reading.

If you're new please join in and if you have questions pop them below and the forum regulars will answer as best we can.

Add new comment

14 comments

Avatar
ianrobo | 10 years ago
0 likes

Not sure we should have people banned for life, after all everyone deserves to have a second chance but sentences should be longer and tougher. I like the Scottish example of 14 years for DDI.

Also I do believe as a driver we should have regular tests every 10 years, the current situation is nonsense really where you pass once for life.

Avatar
DaveG | 10 years ago
0 likes

Signed but, being a cynic here, what difference will it make? How many drivers are out there with no licence already? They get banned, ignore it, get a new car, don't tax or insure it and off they go.

Avatar
PonteD replied to DaveG | 10 years ago
0 likes
DaveG wrote:

Signed but, being a cynic here, what difference will it make? How many drivers are out there with no licence already? They get banned, ignore it, get a new car, don't tax or insure it and off they go.

Shame it's not the Middle Ages, we'd get away with just cutting off their thumbs or something. That'd definitely work, let's see them try and drive with no thumbs.

Avatar
Sevenfold | 10 years ago
0 likes

Signed

Road.cc - can you post a tweet about this? Likely to get a much bigger audience that way.

Avatar
PonteD | 10 years ago
0 likes

From a quick google, it looks like there is currently no maximum ban that can be imposed, only minimums. So a judge could realistically impose a 30 or 40 year ban on these drivers now, but even in serious cases they rarely do.

If this is true, really the pressure needs to come from the government to push for judges to impose longer bans.

Avatar
truffy | 10 years ago
0 likes

I'm all for reckless drivers being banned for life. But I'm not sure what constitutes/differentiates 'careless' and 'dangerous'.

We all have lapses, and no one's perfect*. Some people can learn from honest mistakes and improve, some selfish/arrogant/antisocial fuckers are not interested. It's those latter ones that need to be removed. And I'm not sure how far this proposal goes TBH.

* except some of the non-motorists here on road.cc, who're blessedly perfect  22

Avatar
OnTheRopes replied to truffy | 10 years ago
0 likes
truffy wrote:

I'm all for reckless drivers being banned for life. But I'm not sure what constitutes/differentiates 'careless' and 'dangerous'.

We all have lapses, and no one's perfect*. Some people can learn from honest mistakes and improve, some selfish/arrogant/antisocial fuckers are not interested. It's those latter ones that need to be removed. And I'm not sure how far this proposal goes TBH.

* except some of the non-motorists here on road.cc, who're blessedly perfect  22

I think the clue is in the bit that says 'Causes Death' if you actually read the petition. I don't care whether its careless or dangerous the result is the same.

Avatar
oldstrath replied to truffy | 10 years ago
0 likes
truffy wrote:

I'm all for reckless drivers being banned for life. But I'm not sure what constitutes/differentiates 'careless' and 'dangerous'.

We all have lapses, and no one's perfect*. Some people can learn from honest mistakes and improve, some selfish/arrogant/antisocial fuckers are not interested. It's those latter ones that need to be removed. And I'm not sure how far this proposal goes TBH.

* except some of the non-motorists here on road.cc, who're blessedly perfect  22

Personally don't think it goes far enough. I'd simply say that if you kill someone with a motor vehicle, that's it, no more driving, regardless of how desperately you attempt to shift blame.

As for 'perfect', I agree none of us are. But my imperfections with 120kg of bike and rider moving at 20 mph matter a damn sight less than the imperfections of someone moving 2000kg at 60 mph.

Avatar
Simon E replied to oldstrath | 10 years ago
0 likes
oldstrath wrote:

As for 'perfect', I agree none of us are. But my imperfections with 120kg of bike and rider moving at 20 mph matter a damn sight less than the imperfections of someone moving 2000kg at 60 mph.

Doesn't even need to be that fast - 99% are dead if hit at 50 mph

https://twitter.com/boyplusbike/status/534072974882910208

(and "survive" doesn't necessarily mean you get up and walk away).

I think the powers that be ought to address two pressing issues first:

1. the 8,000+ people that shockingly are still allowed to drive despite having more than 12 points on their licence.
http://road.cc/content/news/81904-more-8000-drivers-have-12-or-more-poin...

2. the hugely variable and sometimes frankly laughable sentences handed out for bad driving. Campaign groups - RDRF, RoadPeace, CTC etc - are working on this one.

Avatar
Bob's Bikes | 10 years ago
0 likes

Done.

Avatar
gazza_d | 10 years ago
0 likes

Signed and tweeted. Lets hope this goes far and wide & is adopted

Avatar
OnTheRopes | 10 years ago
0 likes

Signed and shared

Avatar
PonteD | 10 years ago
0 likes

Done AND shared  16

Avatar
ironmancole | 10 years ago
0 likes

Done.

Latest Comments