Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Am I too light for a steel bike?

I am the lucky owner of a Fairlight Strael 2.0. I like it, but don't quite love it. I was drawn to steel by the promise of a comfortable ride. I've had an old steel frame in the past, and loved the feel, but the Fairlight has always seemed a little bumpy, barely smoother than my alu racer. 

That was until last week, when I loaded up with a heavy rucksack which I had to deliver to a friend. Suddenly the road buzz was gone, smooth as butter. Once I dropped the bag off, the buzz was back.

Am I imagining this, or is this a thing? I'm hoping someone might be able to give an explanation.

What I think is this... the tolerances in the frame (as all bikes) are calculated with the rider weight in mind. I'm relatively light (but not that light - 65kg), and the bag was probably 7-8kg. Being temporarily heavier meant the tension in the frame was just so.

If that's the case, presumably that's true of all bikes, not just steel. Is there a solution other than putting on some weight?

If you're new please join in and if you have questions pop them below and the forum regulars will answer as best we can.

Add new comment

17 comments

Avatar
Nikolai | 4 years ago
1 like

I've noticed that my steel framed Condor only starts behaving like hallowed steel at speed on descents. It just seems to absorb bumps then spring back as if the whole frame is a suspension unit. This fits with what you say if we imagine the velocity increasing my mass. 

Avatar
TheBillder replied to Nikolai | 4 years ago
1 like

Is your mass being increased by your velocity because it's approaching the speed of light, special relativity and all that stuff?

Avatar
Spokesperson | 4 years ago
0 likes

Have I been doing it wrong all along?

I weigh 46kg... sorry eek 46.5kg after lockdown... and all my bikes are steel frame. My tyres are 700x23 or x25 and I normally pump them up to 100 or 110 psi. And I feel every bump and pothole, no matter what I carry in my backpack. But I worry about reducing the pressure in my tyres in case of p%$£@res. I don't like bikes with shock absorbers, as they just absorb energy. I don't like soggy saddles or handlebars. And don't get envious everybody, but it's quite hard for me to put on weight!!

Is there a sweet spot? Technical solutions please. 

Avatar
Nick T replied to Spokesperson | 4 years ago
0 likes

Comfort is subjective, I don't find soft, vague feeling tyres more comfortable personally. At 70kg I keep my 23mm pumped up to 110-120

Avatar
Simon E replied to Spokesperson | 4 years ago
1 like

IME manufacturers' recommendations err on the side of caution (too much rather than too little pressure). I'd suggest that 100 psi is far too high for your weight.

I have tried different pressures over the years and my starting point now for 25mm tyres is to put rider weight (kg) in the back and 5 psi less in the front.

Start with 50 front and 55 rear for 25mm, 5 to 10 psi more for 23mm.

The only time I had a snakebite puncture was last year, when I hit a sharp stone while braking on a steep descent on a back lane. The front tyre was a bit softer than usual, probably about 40 psi, and I was putting considerably more weight on the front tyre than normal. I'm confident that it wouldn't have punctured if the pressure had been what I usually use (~55 psi).

Avatar
wycombewheeler replied to Spokesperson | 4 years ago
1 like

i weigh 80kg, I run 25s at 100psi, I would expect at 46kg 25s should be ok at 70psi or lower with no risk of pinch flats . I don't wonder that you feel every bump.

Avatar
Jez Ash | 4 years ago
6 likes

Well you see, riding a steel bicycle is very much like making love to etc and so on

Avatar
Karbon Kev | 4 years ago
1 like

What a funny thing to ask. Seroiusly, no you're not too light for a steel bike imoi. They're not that heavy.

Avatar
VeloUSA | 4 years ago
2 likes

What size tires and how much PSI F/R do you normally spin on? Your "buzz" could be from too much PSI. Your tires become stiffer and less supple making your ride less compliant. I'm 140lbs/63.5kg. One of my rides is a Cinelli steel frame...zero buzz on 28mm inflated to 80/85 psi.

Avatar
SwissTony replied to VeloUSA | 4 years ago
1 like

I'm running 26mm tyres at 85-90psi. Will let some air out and see how it goes, thanks.

Avatar
Simon E replied to SwissTony | 4 years ago
3 likes

SwissTony wrote:

I'm running 26mm tyres at 85-90psi. Will let some air out and see how it goes, thanks.

Them's hard tyres.

Try 60 front & 65 rear and tweak either way in 5 psi increments.

Then when they need replacing fit some 28s.  1

Avatar
Welsh boy replied to Simon E | 4 years ago
1 like

I couldn't agree less, those pressures are way too low, just drop what you are currently riding by about 5psi, you can always drop it a bit more if you want 

Avatar
Mr Pennington replied to Welsh boy | 4 years ago
0 likes

I concur with Welsh Boy. And pressure way to low will cause pinch flats. If your hands feel the buzz get thicker padded gloves.

Avatar
Chris Hayes | 4 years ago
0 likes

Nah...my son rides one and he's 29kg...on 32mm tyres, however.  Moderate PSI for an 8yr old. 

Avatar
Welsh boy | 4 years ago
8 likes

I think you are overthinking things, the extra weight probably squashed your tyres a bit, try letting a few psi out of your tyres and see how that feels 

Avatar
Nick T replied to Welsh boy | 4 years ago
0 likes

Yep

Avatar
SwissTony replied to Welsh boy | 4 years ago
0 likes

You're right, this makes much more sense

Latest Comments